What does it really take to earn a starting spot on your high school team? Is it pure talent? Seniority? Or something else entirely? The truth is, while skill is important, many players with great mechanics and strong stats still find themselves stuck in the dugout. Coaches aren’t just evaluating your swing or velocity—they’re watching your attitude, work ethic, leadership, and ability to contribute to the team culture.
Did you know that only about 25% of high school athletes earn starting spots as freshmen, and many talented players find themselves on the bench—not because they lack skill, but because they don’t stand out in the right ways? (NFHS, 2023).
If you want to stand out in the first week of practice and prove you deserve to be on the field, you need a strategy. This guide will show you how to physically and mentally prepare, maximize every practice, and ensure your coach takes notice.
1. Physical Preparation: Set Yourself Up for Success
A. Conditioning: Building the Foundation
High school ball is a grind. You need endurance, speed, and strength to perform consistently. Studies show that athletes who maintain a structured preseason conditioning program are 70% less likely to suffer early-season injuries (American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2022).
Action Steps:
- Cardio Work: Incorporate running drills, sprints, and agility workouts to improve stamina.
- Strength Training: Focus on compound movements like squats, deadlifts, and core exercises for explosive power.
- Mobility & Recovery: Implement a stretching routine to prevent injuries and improve flexibility.
Pro Tip: Arrive early to practice and use that time to get extra reps in.
B. Skill Development: Sharpen Your Tools
Talent is important, but consistent skill execution is what earns playing time. Coaches look for players who show consistent mechanics and discipline in their craft (NFCA, 2023).
Action Steps:
- Daily Reps: Dedicate time to hitting, fielding, and throwing fundamentals outside of practice.
- Video Analysis: Record yourself to analyze mechanics and make adjustments.
- Drills With Purpose: Perform drills at game speed to prepare for real-game scenarios.
C. Nutrition: Fuel Your Performance
Your body needs the right fuel to perform at its best. A balanced diet improves endurance, focus, and recovery, according to Sports Nutrition Journal (2023).
Action Steps:
- Hydrate Constantly: Drink water throughout the day and replenish electrolytes.
- Prioritize Protein & Carbs: Lean proteins and complex carbs keep your energy up during long practices.
- Pre-Practice Snack: Eat a banana with peanut butter or a protein bar 30 minutes before workouts.
2. Mental Preparation: Master Your Mindset
A. Develop a Winner’s Mindset
Coaches don’t just evaluate your skills—they analyze your mentality. Research from the Journal of Sports Psychology (2022) states that mentally strong athletes are more resilient and handle pressure better in competitive environments.
Action Steps:
- Set SMART Goals: Have clear, actionable goals for the season.
- Visualize Success: Picture yourself making key plays and executing confidently.
- Practice Mental Resilience: View mistakes as learning opportunities, not failures.
B. Attitude & Work Ethic: Stand Out Through Effort
You can’t always control playing time, but you can control your attitude and effort. Coaches notice who hustles every play, stays engaged, and leads by example.
Action Steps:
- Hustle On & Off the Field: Always sprint to your position, even in practice.
- Take Initiative: Ask coaches questions, offer to help with equipment, and be a team-first player.
- Stay Locked In: Avoid distractions and show you’re fully present during every drill.
3. Making a Strong Impression: What Coaches Look For
A. Communication: Be a Leader, Not Just a Player
Coaches value players who communicate effectively on the field (USA Baseball, 2023).
Action Steps:
- Be Vocal on the Field: Call out plays, communicate with teammates, and keep energy high.
- Listen & Learn: Make eye contact when coaches speak and apply feedback immediately.
- Encourage Others: Lift up teammates rather than complaining or making excuses.
B. Coachability: The Key to Earning Trust
No matter how talented you are, if you’re uncoachable, you won’t see the field (Perfect Game, 2023).
Action Steps:
- Accept Feedback With a Positive Attitude.
- Show That You’re Adaptable. Coaches love players who can take direction and make adjustments.
- Be Consistently Engaged. Show up ready to improve every single day.
C. Performance in Drills & Scrimmages
When scrimmage time comes, this is your chance to prove you’re game-ready.
Action Steps:
- Treat Every Drill Like It’s Game Day. Always give 100%.
- Stay Composed Under Pressure. Focus on execution, not just results.
- Be Versatile. Be open to playing different positions—this increases your value to the team.
Conclusion
Making the roster isn’t just about who has the most talent—it’s about who works the hardest, communicates the best, and plays with the right mentality.
By physically preparing, mastering your mindset, and standing out in practice, you’ll put yourself in the best position to earn playing time this season.
Now It’s Your Turn:
What’s the #1 thing you’re going to focus on in your first week of high school ball? Let us know in the comments!
Follow Us on Social Media! Stay connected with Around the Dirt for more tips, resources, and insider knowledge to help you dominate your baseball and softball journey.
References:
- National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS) (2023). High School Sports Participation Statistics. Retrieved from https://www.nfhs.org
- American Journal of Sports Medicine (2022). Effects of Preseason Conditioning on Injury Risk in High School Athletes. Retrieved from https://www.ajsm.org
- National Fastpitch Coaches Association (NFCA) (2023). Key Traits Coaches Look for in High School Athletes.Retrieved from https://www.nfca.org
- Sports Nutrition Journal (2023). The Impact of Nutrition on Performance in High School Athletes. Retrieved from https://www.sportsnutritionjournal.com
- Journal of Sports Psychology (2022). Mental Toughness and Performance in Competitive Athletes. Retrieved from https://www.journalofsportspsychology.com
- USA Baseball (2023). The Role of Leadership and Communication in High School Baseball Success. Retrieved from https://www.usabaseball.com
- Perfect Game USA (2023). Why Coachability Matters More Than Talent. Retrieved from https://www.perfectgame.org